Fatah and Hamas may be gearing up for Civil War
By Shoshana Bryen
WASHINGTON, D.C.–While the Europeans were busy recasting Jerusalem in the image of Cold War Berlin complete with a wall and two governments-one free and one not-the Palestinians were busy revealing what their presumed state would look like. Follow the threads.
In June, Fatah reaffirmed “the right of armed resistance” (terrorism) in “Palestine.” Last month, Abu Mazen said he would not run in the planned January election. This week, the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) “indefinitely” extended his term and that of the Palestinian parliament, which has not met since 2007. To celebrate, Abu Mazen announced, “We will renew negotiations [with Israel only] if the settlements are completely halted and the 1967 borders recognized as the borders of the Palestinian state.”
That was just to throw you off the trail. Israel is not his problem; Hamas is his problem and it is getting bigger. And the United States is heavily invested in the run up to a potential Palestinian civil war.
Hamas described the extension of Abu Mazen’s term a “coup against the Palestinian constitution.” Spokesman Fawzi Barhoum said, “This is an illegal decision and a political bribe to cover up for the fact that Abbas’ term in office had expired a long time ago.” Hamas celebrated its 20th anniversary with huge demonstrations and an announcement that it will “liberate all of Palestine.” Starting with the West Bank.
According to the Israeli daily Ha’aretz, the Hamas websites contain a 61-page document entitled, “Exclusive and Unique Research: The Detention Philosophy of the Abbas-Dayton Security Apparatuses and Methods of Dealing with Them,” authored by people identifying themselves as “Hamas prisoners in Israel.”
The phrase “Abbas-Dayton security apparatuses” should worry Americans. The United States and Israel have been touting the Palestinian Authority (PA) security forces trained by American Lieutenant General Keith Dayton as key to a future peace between Israel and “the Palestinians.”
Five battalions have been trained and a sixth will start in January, including 2,500 officers trained since 2008-all with American tax dollars. The Obama Administration is planning to finish off ten PA battalions and has allocated another $100 million for the coming year.
The PA security forces have restored a semblance of law and order to the West Bank, permitting increased economic activity and growth, and the removal of dozens of Israeli “checkpoints.” But who are “the Palestinians”? To whom do those forces belong-and to whom will they be loyal under and what circumstances? (Questions with which JINSA readers are familiar.)
Israeli and Americans deflect the issue by saying, “They’re fighting Hamas. The more they do, the less Israel has to do,” implying that the United States has formed a Fatah security force with the cooperation of Israel to counter Hamas. That certainly is the way Hamas sees it.
In the “Exclusive and Unique Research” paper, the authors claim that between June 2007 (when Fatah was ousted from Gaza) and September 2009, there were 22,000 “incidents” initiated by PA security forces against Hamas groups in the West Bank. According to Ha’aretz, the authors say, “The research is intended first and foremost to answer Hamas’ operative needs, i.e., to prepare its members to deal with the Palestinian Authority’s operating methods, and fortify them ahead of time for the travails that lie ahead.”
Allowing for hyperbole and exaggeration in the numbers, the “travails” to which Hamas points means increased friction with Fatah. Although the combination of Israel and Fatah have created better economic and social conditions in the West Bank, Abu Mazen’s popularity in the territory is close to nil (which is why he wouldn’t run in the scheduled election) and Hamas is having some measure of success in painting Fatah with the collaborationist brush-collaborationist with both Israel and the United States. Hamas is, of course, correct. Fatah could not control the West Bank without American and Israeli support. So we are helping Fatah (which touts the legitimacy of “armed resistance” and no negotiations until Israel concedes everything) against Hamas (which demands the liberation of “all of Palestine”).
Yes, as an interim measure, it is better to have day-to-day security and economic cooperation with Fatah than not to have it. But it is an interim measure by Palestinian standards, if not Israeli standards.
Let’s assume the Fatah army is able to defeat the Hamas army and reunifies the Palestinian polity. Come on, it’s the season of miracles.
According to several sources, while Abu Mazen was out of the country trying to undermine the legitimacy of Israel (with a warm welcome in Europe), Palestinian Prime Minister Salim Fayyed-America’s favorite Palestinian-has been at odds with Lieutenant General Dayton and wants to replace American security contractors in 2010 when the current training American contract expires in March.
“Fayyed has come to the conclusion that the U.S. contractors were not providing the training necessary for the Palestinian territories,” a Palestinian source said. Right now, Palestinian forces are trained in Jordan, but the United States has built two new $40 million facilities near Jericho in the West Bank. The source added that Fatah is demanding that PA security forces form the nucleus of a future Palestinian army.
At the level of a single, but still interesting source, Middle East News Line reports that Lieutenant General Dayton no longer has direct access to PA field commanders, but that “the CIA has maintained its contacts with PA commanders… [and] through the U.S. consulate in Jerusalem, has provided funds to PA commanders.”
We ask, yet again, against whom this Palestinian army would fight, to whom it would be loyal. In this season of miracles, we hope for an answer.
**
Bryen is senior director for security policy for the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs. Since Sept. 21, 2008, Waxie Sanitary Supply has sponsored her column in San Diego Jewish World in memory of Morris Wax, who had been a national board member of JINSA.
Recent Posts
- Please go to www.sdjewishworld.com
- Now we’re at www.sdjewishworld.com — come and see!
- Oren pleads for Jewish support for peace
- Maybe not ‘anti-Semitic,’ perhaps Time is ‘anti-semantic’
- Despite flaws, ‘Prodigal Sons’ well worth reading
- Ending settlement freeze teaches Palestinians they can’t get something for nothing
- Possible spy deal and computer malware add intrigue to international scene
- What’s green and rocks? The Shabbat planned by Beth Am
- On Stephen Hawking, genius and music
- Palestinians should realize Israel willing to withdraw for peace, settlements or none
- For Mideast plants, it’s dew or die
- New software may help physicians repair your RNA’s
- However well meaning, Obama has blundered in Middle East
- New bill introduced to penalize bias against students from religious ethnic groups
- The Jews Down Under~Roundup of Australian Jewish News
- La Jolla Playhouse basks in Chaplin’s ‘Limelight’
- J Street leader responds to financing disclosures in Washington Times
- Dissecting President Obama’s U.N. speech
- Actor Richard Dreyfuss headlines Oct. 9 county library book festival
- Jewish community well represented in local ‘Star’ awards
- Tense times on front lines of Jerusalem neighborhoods
- Two IDF soldiers to tour San Diego schools Oct. 6
- ‘MiXtape’ and ‘The Full Monty’ enliven local theatre scene
- Commentary: USC campus police abet anti-Israel propagandists
- Obama to U.N.: Israel’s existence not a matter for debate
Archives
Pages
Categories
- 1954~Rosh Hashanah
- Aaron Elias
- Abbe Wolfsheimer Stutz
- Abu Dhabi
- Adam Schiff
- Adventures in SD History
- Afghanistan
- Airlines
- Albania
- Alex Liff
- Algeria
- Allyson Schwartz
- Antartica
- Anthony Weiner
- Anti-Semitism
- Arab League
- Argentina
- Arlen Specter
- Armenia
- Arnold Flick
- Australia
- Austria
- Azerbaijan
- Bahrain
- Bangladeh
- Barbados
- Barbara Boxer
- Barbara Kay
- Barney Frank
- Barry Rubin
- Baseball
- basketball
- Belarus
- Belgium
- Benjamin Cardin
- Bermuda
- Biking
- Bob Filner
- Bodybuilding
- Bolivia
- Bonnie Dumanis
- Books
- Bosnia and Herzegovina
- Botswana
- Boxing
- Brad Sherman
- Brazil
- Britain
- Bruce F. Lowitt
- Bruce Kesler
- Bruce S. Ticker
- Bulgaria
- Burma
- Cambodia
- Cameroon
- Canada
- Canary Islands
- Carine Chitayat
- Carl Levin
- Carol Ann Goldstein
- Carol Davis
- Cayman Islands
- Central African Republic
- Chad
- Chanukah
- Charles Schumer
- Chile
- China
- Claire Gold
- Colombia
- comedy
- Community Greetings
- Congo
- Costa Rica
- Countries
- cricket
- Croatia
- Cruise Lines
- Cuba
- Curacao
- Cynthia Citron
- Cynthia Weisfield
- Cyprus
- Czech Republic
- Czecheslovakia (historical)
- Dan Schaffer
- Dance
- Danny Bloom
- Darrell Steinberg
- David Amos
- David Strom
- Delta
- Denmark
- Dianne Feinstein
- Donald H. Harrison
- Dorothea Shefer-Vanson
- Dubai
- Ecuador
- Ed Koch
- Eddie Rosenberg
- Egypt
- Eileen Wingard
- El Al
- Equatorial Guinea
- Eric Cantor
- Eritrea
- Estonia
- Ethiopia
- European Union
- Finland
- First Amendment~Religion
- Football
- France
- Frank Lautenberg
- Franklin Gaylis
- Fred Reiss
- G8
- Gail Feinstein Forman
- Gail Umeham
- Garry Fabian
- Gary Ackerman
- Gary Rotto
- Gaza
- Georgia {Gruziya}
- Germany
- Gerry Greber
- Gert Thaler
- Ghana
- golf
- Greece
- Guatemala
- Haiti
- Hal Wingard
- Henry Waxman
- historic places
- Hockey
- Holland America
- Holocaust~Shoah
- Honduras
- Hong Kong
- Howard Berman
- Howard Wayne
- Hungary
- Iceland
- India
- Indonesia
- Interfaith
- Ira Ruskin
- Ira Sharkansky
- Iran
- Iraq
- Ireland
- Irv Justman
- Isaac Yetiv
- Israel
- Italy
- Ivory Coast
- J. Zel Lurie
- Jack Forman
- Jack Markell
- Jamaica
- Jan Schakowsky
- Janis Colton
- Japan
- Jared Polis
- Jay N. Jacobson
- Jay Tell
- Jeanette Friedman
- Jeanette Katzir
- Jerrold Nadler
- Jewish license plates
- Jewish Public Officials
- Joel A. Moskowitz
- Joellyn Zollman
- Joey Seymour
- John Adler
- John Yarmuth
- Jordan
- Joseph Lieberman
- Judaism
- Judy Lash Balint
- Kashif Shahzada
- Kathi Diamant
- Kazakhstan
- Kenya
- kick boxing
- Kuwait
- Kyrgystan
- Lag B'Omer
- Latvia
- Laurel Corona
- Lebanon
- Liberia
- Libya
- Lifestyles
- Linda Capeloto Sendowski
- Lithuania
- Lloyd Levy
- Lorne Mallin
- Luxembourg
- Lynne Thrope
- Macedonia
- Malaysia
- Maldives
- Mali
- Marc Yaffe
- Marissa Palin
- Marquesas Islands
- Marshall Islands
- Marti Emerald
- Marty Block
- Mauritania
- Mauritius
- Mexico
- Michael Bloomberg
- Micronesia
- Moldova
- Mongolia
- Morocco
- Morris Casuto
- Movies
- Music
- Myanmar/Burma
- Natasha Josefowitz
- Nauru
- Netherlands
- New Zealand
- Nicaragua
- Nigeria
- Nita Lowey
- Norman Greene
- Norman Manson
- North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)
- North Korea
- Norway
- obituaries
- Oman
- Opera
- Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
- Organization of American States (OAS)
- Our Writers
- Pakistan
- Palau
- Palestinian Authority
- Panama
- Paul Greenberg
- Peru
- Pesach
- Peter Eisner
- Philippines
- Poetry
- Poland
- Portugal
- Puerto Rico (US territory)
- Purim
- Qatar
- Quartet (for Mideast Peace)
- R-e-s-p-e-c-t
- Rabbi Baruch Lederman
- Rabbi Ben Kamin
- Rabbi Dow Marmur
- Rabbi Leonard Rosenthal
- Rabbi Philip Graubart
- Rabbi Simcha Weinstein
- Rabbi William N. Kramer
- Randy Fadem
- Recipes
- Recommended reading and viewing
- Rhodesia-historical
- Richard C. Holbrooke
- Robert Wilson
- Romania
- Ron Wyden
- Rosh Hashanah
- Roz Rothstein
- Rugby
- Running
- Russell Feingold
- Russia
- Rwanda
- Sammy Samuels
- San Diego
- San Diego history
- Sander Levin
- Sara Appel-Lennon
- Saudi Arabia
- Science
- Senegal
- Serbia
- Shavuot
- Sheila Orysiek
- Sheldon Silver
- Shelley Berkley
- Shonda file
- Shoshana Bryen
- Singapore
- Slovakia
- Slovenia
- Soccer
- Solomon Islands
- Somalia
- South Africa
- South Korea
- Soviet Union (historical)
- Spain
- Sports
- Sri Lanka
- Steve Cohen
- Steve Hofstetter
- Steve Israel
- Steve Kagen
- Steve Poizner
- Steve Rothman
- Sudan
- Sukkot
- Surfing
- Susan Davis
- Sweden
- Switzerland
- Syria
- Taiwan
- Tajikstan
- Tanzania
- Tashlich (part of Rosh Hashanah)
- Ted Parker
- television
- Tennis
- terror
- Thailand
- The Arts
- Theatre
- Tibet
- Tisha B'Av
- Toby Klein Greenwald
- Tonga
- Travel
- Tu B'Shevat
- Tunisia
- Turkey
- Turkmenistan
- Tuvulu
- Uganda
- Ukraine
- Ulla Hadar
- Uncategorized
- United Arab Emirates
- United Kingdom
- United Nations
- United States of America
- Uruguay
- Uzbekistan
- Vanuatu
- Vatican City
- Venezuela
- Vietnam
- Virgin Islands (U.S. territory)
- Visual Arts
- water polo
- West Bank
- Yachting
- Yemen
- Yiftach Levy
- Yom Ha'atzma'ut
- Yom HaShoah
- Yom HaZikaron
- Yom Kippur
- Yom Yerushalayim
- Yonatan Peres
- Yosef Rabin
- Yugoslavia (historic)
- Yvonne Greenberg
- Zambia
- Zimbabwe