Educational and patriotic thoughts about American music
By David Amos
SAN DIEGO–Earlier this month we celebrated our Independence Day. My thoughts brought me to the importance of American music, and the shameful neglect we have allowed music education to be. Part of this was stimulated by an article in the editorial section of the San Diego Union-Tribune by John M. Eger, on July 8.
But first, let me share with you a sensitive, meaningful poem by an anonymous music teacher, circa, well….anytime:
WHY I TEACH MUSIC:
Not because I expect you to major in music.
Not because I expect you to play or sing all your life.
Not so you can relax or have fun.
But…
So you will be human,
So you will recognize beauty,
So you will be closer to an infinite beyond this world, So you will have something to cling to, So you will have more love, compassion, more gentleness,
More good….in short, more life!
Of what value will it be to make a prosperous living
Unless you know how to live?
On American and modern music: We have been conditioned to believe that if it is called “modern music”, or if the name of the composer is unknown to us, it is probably ugly and not worth our attention. Yes, there is a natural tendency to dislike the unknown, but in music, sadly, we do not even give it a chance to redeem itself. Even the late Karl Haas (from the enormously popular radio program “Adventures in Good Music”) told me that he sometimes received fan letters which warned him that if he as much as mentions the fact that he was about to play music from the Twentieth Century, the radio would be turned off immediately. This is tragic; it is cultural suicide.
I remember sadly an evening of music played by the San Diego Symphony, maybe fifteen years ago. In the first half was music by Robert Schumann, and after intermission, the conductor programmed the fabulous Concerto for Orchestra by Béla Bartók. The latter is to me one of the greatest compositions ever. Period. You can imagine my disappointment, pain, and frustration to see more than half of the audience trampling its way to Symphony Hall’s exits, just to avoid listening to Bartók in the second half! In retrospect, the program order should have been reversed.
The fact is, that there is a vast amount of modern music, a lot of it composed by Americans, which is accessible, enjoyable, even at a first hearing, and very melodious. In other words, it is what I call “listener friendly”.
After being so involved with the subject of American orchestral music (I gave a lecture on the subject to the music faculty of Hebrew University in Jerusalem), I have had many a talk with musicians, critics, and music lovers. One salient fact stands out: The American public has an inferiority complex about its own music. We tend to believe that if it originated in Europe, it is probably better, and if it is from the U.S., it will be lacking in depth and lasting value. Only history will eventually resolve this, but I have noticed in my various travels and conversations that most natives from other countries support and proudly believe in their own heritage, whether it be historic or contemporary. Audiences and musicians alike enthusiastically program and attend concerts of their own composers in Canada, Poland, Denmark, England, Mexico, and the former Soviet republics. I am sure that it is the same in many other places; but don’t get me started on Israel!
Curiously, when I was invited to guest conduct in Lithuania in 1992, when working out the repertory to be performed at the concerts, I was politely asked to “please not bring any Copland, Gershwin, or Bernstein”. At first, I was surprised and a bit annoyed, already thinking of several hidden implications from that request. But after directly asking the director of the Lithuanian Philharmonic as to “why”, the answer was surprising: “We don’t want you to bring us music from these composers, because we program them too frequently, and they are very popular here. We want you to bring to us some different American music”. So, I brought them Paul Creston, Alan Hovhaness, Norman Dello-Joio, Gian Carlo Menotti, and Ernest Bloch. After the fact, the musicians told me how much they enjoyed playing the music of these composers, and the audiences seemed responsive and enthusiastic, in both Vilnius and Kaunas.
As an aside, I was told by a cellist of the Vilnius orchestra, “We are glad that you brought us the music of Bloch. During the Soviet regime, we were not allowed to perform his music, just because he was Jewish”. He also proudly showed me a printed program for later in the month, where he was performing Bloch’s Schelomo, the Hebraic Rhapsody for Cello and Orchestra.
Getting back to our American heritage, it is best to quote the words and spirit of one of our greatest composers, Charles Ives. He not only preached, but practiced the concept of “Wake up, America! The culture and traditions of Europe are fine, but stand up, support, and enjoy your own wonderful music”.
I fully endorse that. Let us strive to discover and enjoy totally unknown and lesser known treasures of our past and present. Be careful, you may enjoy what you hear.
*
Amos is conductor of the Tifereth Israel Community Orchestra and a guest conductor of professional orchestras around the world
Recent Posts
- Please go to www.sdjewishworld.com
- Now we’re at www.sdjewishworld.com — come and see!
- Oren pleads for Jewish support for peace
- Maybe not ‘anti-Semitic,’ perhaps Time is ‘anti-semantic’
- Despite flaws, ‘Prodigal Sons’ well worth reading
- Ending settlement freeze teaches Palestinians they can’t get something for nothing
- Possible spy deal and computer malware add intrigue to international scene
- What’s green and rocks? The Shabbat planned by Beth Am
- On Stephen Hawking, genius and music
- Palestinians should realize Israel willing to withdraw for peace, settlements or none
- For Mideast plants, it’s dew or die
- New software may help physicians repair your RNA’s
- However well meaning, Obama has blundered in Middle East
- New bill introduced to penalize bias against students from religious ethnic groups
- The Jews Down Under~Roundup of Australian Jewish News
- La Jolla Playhouse basks in Chaplin’s ‘Limelight’
- J Street leader responds to financing disclosures in Washington Times
- Dissecting President Obama’s U.N. speech
- Actor Richard Dreyfuss headlines Oct. 9 county library book festival
- Jewish community well represented in local ‘Star’ awards
- Tense times on front lines of Jerusalem neighborhoods
- Two IDF soldiers to tour San Diego schools Oct. 6
- ‘MiXtape’ and ‘The Full Monty’ enliven local theatre scene
- Commentary: USC campus police abet anti-Israel propagandists
- Obama to U.N.: Israel’s existence not a matter for debate
Archives
Pages
Categories
- 1954~Rosh Hashanah
- Aaron Elias
- Abbe Wolfsheimer Stutz
- Abu Dhabi
- Adam Schiff
- Adventures in SD History
- Afghanistan
- Airlines
- Albania
- Alex Liff
- Algeria
- Allyson Schwartz
- Antartica
- Anthony Weiner
- Anti-Semitism
- Arab League
- Argentina
- Arlen Specter
- Armenia
- Arnold Flick
- Australia
- Austria
- Azerbaijan
- Bahrain
- Bangladeh
- Barbados
- Barbara Boxer
- Barbara Kay
- Barney Frank
- Barry Rubin
- Baseball
- basketball
- Belarus
- Belgium
- Benjamin Cardin
- Bermuda
- Biking
- Bob Filner
- Bodybuilding
- Bolivia
- Bonnie Dumanis
- Books
- Bosnia and Herzegovina
- Botswana
- Boxing
- Brad Sherman
- Brazil
- Britain
- Bruce F. Lowitt
- Bruce Kesler
- Bruce S. Ticker
- Bulgaria
- Burma
- Cambodia
- Cameroon
- Canada
- Canary Islands
- Carine Chitayat
- Carl Levin
- Carol Ann Goldstein
- Carol Davis
- Cayman Islands
- Central African Republic
- Chad
- Chanukah
- Charles Schumer
- Chile
- China
- Claire Gold
- Colombia
- comedy
- Community Greetings
- Congo
- Costa Rica
- Countries
- cricket
- Croatia
- Cruise Lines
- Cuba
- Curacao
- Cynthia Citron
- Cynthia Weisfield
- Cyprus
- Czech Republic
- Czecheslovakia (historical)
- Dan Schaffer
- Dance
- Danny Bloom
- Darrell Steinberg
- David Amos
- David Strom
- Delta
- Denmark
- Dianne Feinstein
- Donald H. Harrison
- Dorothea Shefer-Vanson
- Dubai
- Ecuador
- Ed Koch
- Eddie Rosenberg
- Egypt
- Eileen Wingard
- El Al
- Equatorial Guinea
- Eric Cantor
- Eritrea
- Estonia
- Ethiopia
- European Union
- Finland
- First Amendment~Religion
- Football
- France
- Frank Lautenberg
- Franklin Gaylis
- Fred Reiss
- G8
- Gail Feinstein Forman
- Gail Umeham
- Garry Fabian
- Gary Ackerman
- Gary Rotto
- Gaza
- Georgia {Gruziya}
- Germany
- Gerry Greber
- Gert Thaler
- Ghana
- golf
- Greece
- Guatemala
- Haiti
- Hal Wingard
- Henry Waxman
- historic places
- Hockey
- Holland America
- Holocaust~Shoah
- Honduras
- Hong Kong
- Howard Berman
- Howard Wayne
- Hungary
- Iceland
- India
- Indonesia
- Interfaith
- Ira Ruskin
- Ira Sharkansky
- Iran
- Iraq
- Ireland
- Irv Justman
- Isaac Yetiv
- Israel
- Italy
- Ivory Coast
- J. Zel Lurie
- Jack Forman
- Jack Markell
- Jamaica
- Jan Schakowsky
- Janis Colton
- Japan
- Jared Polis
- Jay N. Jacobson
- Jay Tell
- Jeanette Friedman
- Jeanette Katzir
- Jerrold Nadler
- Jewish license plates
- Jewish Public Officials
- Joel A. Moskowitz
- Joellyn Zollman
- Joey Seymour
- John Adler
- John Yarmuth
- Jordan
- Joseph Lieberman
- Judaism
- Judy Lash Balint
- Kashif Shahzada
- Kathi Diamant
- Kazakhstan
- Kenya
- kick boxing
- Kuwait
- Kyrgystan
- Lag B'Omer
- Latvia
- Laurel Corona
- Lebanon
- Liberia
- Libya
- Lifestyles
- Linda Capeloto Sendowski
- Lithuania
- Lloyd Levy
- Lorne Mallin
- Luxembourg
- Lynne Thrope
- Macedonia
- Malaysia
- Maldives
- Mali
- Marc Yaffe
- Marissa Palin
- Marquesas Islands
- Marshall Islands
- Marti Emerald
- Marty Block
- Mauritania
- Mauritius
- Mexico
- Michael Bloomberg
- Micronesia
- Moldova
- Mongolia
- Morocco
- Morris Casuto
- Movies
- Music
- Myanmar/Burma
- Natasha Josefowitz
- Nauru
- Netherlands
- New Zealand
- Nicaragua
- Nigeria
- Nita Lowey
- Norman Greene
- Norman Manson
- North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)
- North Korea
- Norway
- obituaries
- Oman
- Opera
- Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
- Organization of American States (OAS)
- Our Writers
- Pakistan
- Palau
- Palestinian Authority
- Panama
- Paul Greenberg
- Peru
- Pesach
- Peter Eisner
- Philippines
- Poetry
- Poland
- Portugal
- Puerto Rico (US territory)
- Purim
- Qatar
- Quartet (for Mideast Peace)
- R-e-s-p-e-c-t
- Rabbi Baruch Lederman
- Rabbi Ben Kamin
- Rabbi Dow Marmur
- Rabbi Leonard Rosenthal
- Rabbi Philip Graubart
- Rabbi Simcha Weinstein
- Rabbi William N. Kramer
- Randy Fadem
- Recipes
- Recommended reading and viewing
- Rhodesia-historical
- Richard C. Holbrooke
- Robert Wilson
- Romania
- Ron Wyden
- Rosh Hashanah
- Roz Rothstein
- Rugby
- Running
- Russell Feingold
- Russia
- Rwanda
- Sammy Samuels
- San Diego
- San Diego history
- Sander Levin
- Sara Appel-Lennon
- Saudi Arabia
- Science
- Senegal
- Serbia
- Shavuot
- Sheila Orysiek
- Sheldon Silver
- Shelley Berkley
- Shonda file
- Shoshana Bryen
- Singapore
- Slovakia
- Slovenia
- Soccer
- Solomon Islands
- Somalia
- South Africa
- South Korea
- Soviet Union (historical)
- Spain
- Sports
- Sri Lanka
- Steve Cohen
- Steve Hofstetter
- Steve Israel
- Steve Kagen
- Steve Poizner
- Steve Rothman
- Sudan
- Sukkot
- Surfing
- Susan Davis
- Sweden
- Switzerland
- Syria
- Taiwan
- Tajikstan
- Tanzania
- Tashlich (part of Rosh Hashanah)
- Ted Parker
- television
- Tennis
- terror
- Thailand
- The Arts
- Theatre
- Tibet
- Tisha B'Av
- Toby Klein Greenwald
- Tonga
- Travel
- Tu B'Shevat
- Tunisia
- Turkey
- Turkmenistan
- Tuvulu
- Uganda
- Ukraine
- Ulla Hadar
- Uncategorized
- United Arab Emirates
- United Kingdom
- United Nations
- United States of America
- Uruguay
- Uzbekistan
- Vanuatu
- Vatican City
- Venezuela
- Vietnam
- Virgin Islands (U.S. territory)
- Visual Arts
- water polo
- West Bank
- Yachting
- Yemen
- Yiftach Levy
- Yom Ha'atzma'ut
- Yom HaShoah
- Yom HaZikaron
- Yom Kippur
- Yom Yerushalayim
- Yonatan Peres
- Yosef Rabin
- Yugoslavia (historic)
- Yvonne Greenberg
- Zambia
- Zimbabwe